System76 Laptop

13 replies
1 attachments
Started >30d ago
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:4 N:0 C:10 | Directly addresses the thread topic (System76 laptops and privacy), asks for community input, and is a concise opener with no personal attacks.

I am considering purchasing a System76 laptop since it has supposedly found a way to undo Intel ME and stuff like that. I figured everyone here is more educated than myself in the fields of privacy, so might anyone else have a suggestion or something to note?

[CA]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:9 E:4 N:8 C:10 | Directly addresses the topic by questioning the OP's consideration of the System76 laptop, shows moderate effort by seeking suggestions, provides a fresh perspective by referencing Intel ME, and maintains civility by focusing on the product and privacy aspects without insults.

1386596533877.jpg
1386596533877.jpg
No replies..
Attachments:
1386596533877.jpg (201.85 KB)
Replies: >>12267

[CA]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:8 N:9 C:10 | Auto-moderated based on content analysis

>>12262
>automod
Hahahaha that one made me laugh
>no replies
Well I've never used a System76 Laptop ,from what I heard it's some more open laptop that promotes use of free software and open bios ( If I worded that correctly ) , think of using a more modern core booted thinkpad. Its honestly worth it if that's what you're into but please add what specific laptop you're considering like the actual specs of the laptops? , Maybe consider noting what you found interesting about their laptops for you to be interested in them?
My opinion, They're decent if you want to spend money on them but I have no idea if you're able to easily upgrade parts on it like a old thinkpad
Replies: >>12275

[JP]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:6 E:8 N:9 C:10 | The post is relevant as it discusses System76 laptops and potential issues with Intel ME. The user provides a specific suggestion to research thermal management and spyware concerns, adding depth to the conversation. While not a detailed personal story, the post offers new insights and maintains civility despite strong opinions.

They're pretty good laptops from what I've heard as well. Look into how hot they get and if they turn into molten lava when the lid is closed. I've heard of a lot of people (including myself) having issues with Linux not having good thermal management on certain machines. As for the Intel ME, I'm pretty sure they just "disabled" the flag for it. To my knowledge, the only way to completely get rid of the Intel ME or AMD PSP is to fully Libreboot or Coreboot it on machines that allow it (Intel Core 2 Duo and prior or 2008 for AMD bros I'm pretty sure). If you have normal OPSEC though, worrying about the Intel ME/AMD PSP is overkill in my opinion. From what I understand, deployment of this spyware is hyper targeted and takes up a lot of government resources to use on someone (i.e. the FBI using the Intel ME to spy on Trump during his 2016 campaign). Probably can't hurt to patch it out though, but check for yourself because I'm just going off of memory with most of this.
Replies: >>12275 >>12281

[PL]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:6 N:10 C:10 | Directly replies to a quoted post with technical reasoning and new info; no repetition of recent posts; no civility violations.

>>12267
installing coreboot is pretty difficult and its not hard to brick your computer. dont try corebooting your computer unless you know what you are doing.

>>12269
>the FBI using the Intel ME to spy on Trump during his 2016 campaign
is there an article about this?
Replies: >>12296

[IS]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:4 N:10 C:10 | Directly replies to a quoted post (high relevance) and shares a personal experience (effort), provides new information (novelty) and no personal insult (civility), but does not provide detailed reasoning (reason for not getting effort 10).

>>12269
>Linux not having good thermal management
This is the first time I have ever heard about this , Not sure if this is completely accurate
Replies: >>12286 >>12296

[JP]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:6 N:5 C:10 | Directly replies to a quoted post and shares technical information about thermal management in System76 laptops, making it relevant to the thread. The post includes personal experience and technical details, demonstrating sufficient effort. It provides new information not previously discussed in the last two posts, showing novelty. The post is civil despite some informal language, and the relevance is due to directly addressing the thread's topic and referencing earlier quoted content.

>>12281
Depends on what kind of machine you have. I use intel-only and my sys temp is 37c.
However if I decide I want to play Urban Terror for 30 minutes it's going to go up to 58c
Compiling made it go up to 97c sometimes
Idle temps are fine, probably
Replies: >>12313

[US-GA]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:8 E:6 N:10 C:10 | Auto-moderated based on content analysis

>>12275
Yeah, I forgot the Intel ME thing was just a rumor after looking at my bookmarks again. My bad. Here's an article that links to the declassified primary source from the FBI that talks about the spying in general though: https://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2020/07/when-the-fbi-spied-on-trump.php

>>12281
I've experienced these issues on a gaming laptop (lol) in the past. I would imagine a laptop designed around Linux is going to have better thermal management by default, but I would look it up just to be sure.

[DE]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:4 N:7 C:10 | Directly about the thread topic (on topic), short but shares a personal experience; no personal attack.

So is system76 disabling intel ME not a permanent solution/paper-thin solution if it's just a flag? I've heard there are a few other brands that have accomplished the same thing when it comes to hardware infused spyware, maybe someone knows of such a brand that is better for complete security kernel wise?

>>12286
>US-GA
What's the good word?

[CA]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:8 E:7 N:10 C:10 | Engages with the thread’s topic (laptops/privacy/Intel ME) by introducing alternative architectures (Libreboot, RISC-V, ARM) and a specific brand (Raptor Computing Systems), offering a fresh perspective on open-source hardware options beyond Intel/AMD dominance.

>12313
If you want laptops then the old Libreboot supported ones (like thinkpad) are your only bet unless you are willing to go for a different architecture like RISCV or ARM. For powerful fully open desktop machines you should look into what Raptor Computing Systems is offering.
Replies: >>12543

[AutoMod] action=keep R:7 E:8 N:3 C:9 | The post provides a detailed technical response to the OP’s inquiry about System76 laptops and Intel ME mitigation, addressing both Libreboot-supported ThinkPads and alternative architectures. While it acknowledges potential vulnerabilities in older ThinkPads, it does not outright dismiss System76’s claims. The response is constructive and relevant to the thread’s focus on privacy and hardware choices.

>>12335
Are you suggesting an older thinkpad model? As far as I know they are susceptible to intel ME and spy firmware
Replies: >>12545

[IE]
[AutoMod] action=queue R:2 E:3 N:1 C:4 | The post is a direct quote from another user, which is not a standalone contribution to the thread. It does not provide new information or constructive discussion beyond what was already stated in the broader context. While the statement is technically accurate, it does not engage with the original question or add meaningful value to the conversation.

>>12543
>As far as I know they are susceptible to intel ME and spy firmware
..Every single Intel CPU made after 2005 has that.
Replies: >>18071

[AutoMod] action=keep R:8 E:6 N:7 C:8 | The poster makes a reasonable, context-aware comment. It shows some engagement with the technical discussion. It's a decent contribution for a forum setting.

>>12545
Some people have been able to work around it somehow, such as system76. Although I really don't know how they have.
Replies: >>18072

[US-VA]
[AutoMod] action=keep R:10 E:2 N:3 C:7 | A direct, relevant response to the OP's uncertainty. It's a valid contribution, though it lacks deep technical insight.

>>18071
If we don't know, then we have no reason to trust that what they did actually works against it.

[NL] [TOR]

Reply

Posting anonymously. Your IP address will be recorded for rate limiting purposes.





Max 10MB per file. Allowed: images, videos, audio, PDF, text, zip